Women, Queer Faith, and Reform
Reform rises: abuse exposés, women pressing for ordination, queer-affirming liturgies, and schisms over marriage and abortion after Dobbs. Hashtags turn into synods and street vigils.
Episode Narrative
In the years from 1991 to 2016, Australia bore witness to a striking transformation in its religious landscape. The population identifying as Christian, which once stood proudly at 74%, fell to a mere 52%. Within this shift, a significant wave of secularization emerged, as nearly one-third of Australians began to report having no religion at all — 30% to be precise. This decline was not merely a passing phase; it reflected decades of gradual but accelerating change, a broad societal shift away from organized faith and towards a landscape where belief became increasingly personal and varied.
Amid this backdrop of transformation, the emergence of diverse religions marked a significant chapter in Australia's evolving narrative. Between 2006 and 2016, Hinduism grew impressively, bolstered by waves of immigration from South Asia. Alongside this, Islam and Buddhism also claimed a modest yet important foothold in the nation’s spiritual tapestry. This shift toward a more multicultural religious identity underscored the increasing complexity of Australian society, as age-old traditions from far-off lands began to merge with the homegrown beliefs of its populace.
Across the world, similar narratives unfolded. In the United States, by 2012, 20% of adults claimed to have no religious preference — a dramatic rise from just 7% in 1987. Political tensions, particularly a backlash against the religious right, played a critical role in this shift, drawing younger generations into a more secular lifestyle. Here, the core beliefs that once shaped society remained relatively stable, yet many found themselves increasingly detached from religious institutions.
This detachment resonated deeply with the Millennial generation. By 2014, nearly one-third of American Millennials identified as secular — not just in terms of their affiliation but in their belief systems. This marked a striking contrast to preceding generations at the same age. As Millennial beliefs took root, they too were influenced by the structures around them, showcasing a generational shift in a society grappling with its identity.
From 2016 to 2021, the rise of the 'nones,' those who reject the label of any religious affiliation, revealed a patchwork across various U.S. states. In regions already possessing higher proportions of religiously unaffiliated individuals, the increase was particularly steep. This hinted at a cultural momentum driving secularization forward, shaped by local experiences and histories that crafted unique spiritual landscapes — some flourishing while others remained more anchored in tradition.
As these transformative currents surged through societies, the United Kingdom found its own story unfolding. Between 2019 and 2020, a study guided by the Avon Longitudinal data uncovered that a significant number of young adults, born in the early 1990s, identified as 'nones,' agnostic, or atheist. Among them, about 3% adhered to ‘other’ belief systems, reflecting a growing inclination toward a personalized approach to spirituality. They navigated their faith journeys outside the traditional confines, searching instead for meaning in a fluid and rapidly changing world.
The COVID-19 pandemic thrust humanity into a global crisis, reshaping many aspects of life and society. In 2020, as lockdowns confined individuals to their homes, a curious phenomenon occurred: global searches for 'prayer' surged 10% above baseline levels, amidst declining physical gatherings. This crisis-driven return to private religiosity mirrored a complex relationship where hope flickered in moments of despair, drawing many back to faith, albeit in new and personal ways.
Amid the pandemic's sweeping influence, research across the United States indicated a nuanced reality. Self-reported decreases in religiosity — evident in diminished importance, prayer, and community connection — often correlated with lower overall flourishing. This insight unveiled a multifaceted relationship between crisis and faith. Was it possible that, even in a secularizing world, the human spirit longed for connection, grounding, and community?
In the quest for belonging and meaning, various identities began to surface. In 2021, a significant observation revealed that while most sexual minorities tended to be less religious, Black sexual minority women with college degrees exhibited unique patterns, meditating more frequently than any other group. This intersectional approach to spirituality illustrated the distinct ways individuals navigate faith, identity, and experience.
Further examinations in 2022 highlighted a surprising exploration among German Muslim youth. A considerable 58% maintained high religiosity into early adulthood. This finding challenged assumptions that religious decline was universal among young people in Western societies, illuminating the diverse responses to faith shaped by culture, context, and community.
The threads of this intricate narrative continued to weave throughout Europe. In 2023, a study encompassing over 224,000 Europeans suggested that generational openness to change played a significant role in the decline of religiosity. This shift indicated that evolving cultural values — not simply age or life stage — were potent forces steering individuals away from traditional beliefs towards a less structured, more personal conception of spirituality.
As the clock ticked toward 2024, Brazil showcased the reminder of faith's persistent power. Here, women were reported to be more than twice as likely as men to identify with a religion, while Black and Brown Brazilians maintained higher rates of religiosity than their White counterparts. Yet, paradoxically, higher income and education often corresponded with lower religiosity, reflecting the complex interplay between identity, experience, and belief systems.
Meanwhile, the Philippines ventured into an exploration of cultural and religious education. Traditional madrasah education within the Sama Dilaut community sought to preserve both cultural heritage and religious identity. Yet, even amid this vibrant endeavor, students faced significant marginalization and resource gaps, depicting a persistent tension between faith, culture, and the quest for inclusion.
In Iran, experimental spiritual training for male high school students in 2024-2025 yielded noteworthy benefits. Those engaged in structured spiritual interventions demonstrated significant improvements in interpersonal relationships and personality development. This suggested that even within secularizing societies, there might exist pathways through faith that foster personal and social growth.
As the world turned its attention towards the UK in 2025, demographic predictors of religious and spiritual beliefs uncovered complex patterns of influence. Factors such as gender, income, and education played dual roles, with income showing a stronger connection to attendance than to overall affiliation, emphasizing the multitude of factors that shape religious engagement.
Throughout the past decades, the rise of the internet significantly impacted religious affiliation. Between 1991 and 2025, the increasing prevalence of online platforms correlated with a notable decline in organized faith. Moderate internet use was linked to an 18% reduced likelihood of religious affiliation, while heavy use contributed to a staggering 42% drop. This shift illustrated technology's seismic role in reshaping how individuals connect with spirituality and with each other.
This trajectory echoed throughout the globe, capturing significant shifts in religious diversity. After World War II, the global Religious Diversity Index surged by over 61%, particularly in Latin America — a testament to migration's power and the liberalization of religious markets worldwide. The narrative of reform, innovation, and transformation danced across borders, as individuals found new vessels for belief.
The experiences in Sweden further complicated the narrative of relentless secularization. Deregulation of the religious market after 1970 led to a resurgence in religious interest among younger generations. This twist in the story challenges the commonly held belief gaps between faith and modernity mainstreamed across Northern Europe.
Amid these waves of change between 2020 and 2025, qualitative studies showcased varying responses to faith during the pandemic. Some individuals turned back towards religion, while others stepped away, creating a dual narrative. Those who deepened their devotion during this time reported heightened levels of gratitude, awe, and meaning, illustrating faith as both a source of crisis response and existential reflection.
As we traverse this history, we observe the emergence of a broad category identified as "spiritual but not religious." This growing population reflects a remarkable cultural shift towards individualized, non-dogmatic beliefs crafted from diverse traditions. With each story, every detail we gather offers a mirror to our societies — a reminder of the complex, fluid nature of faith in the modern world.
As we conclude this journey through the changing landscapes of belief, one question lingers in the air: what does the future hold for faith in all its myriad forms? Will humanity continue its dance with spirituality, evolving our searches for meaning, community, and transcendence? Only time will reveal the answers as the tale of women, queer faith, and reform continues to unfold.
Highlights
- 1991–2016: In Australia, Christianity declined from 74% to 52% of the population, while the proportion of people reporting “no religion” rose to nearly one-third (30%), reflecting a decades-long, accelerating trend of secularization. (Visual: Line chart of religious affiliation over time.)
- 2006–2016: Hinduism in Australia showed the most significant growth among non-Christian religions, attributed to immigration from South Asia, while Islam (2.6%) and Buddhism (2.4%) also grew, highlighting increasing religious diversity. (Visual: Pie chart of religious demographics by decade.)
- 2012: In the United States, 20% of adults claimed no religious preference, up from 7% in 1987, driven by political backlash against the religious right and generational change, though core religious beliefs remained relatively stable. (Visual: Bar graph of “nones” over time.)
- 2014: Nearly a third of American Millennials were secular not only in affiliation but also in belief in God, religiosity, and religious service attendance — a much higher rate than previous generations at the same age. (Visual: Generational comparison infographic.)
- 2016–2021: The “rise of the nones” in the U.S. was uneven across states, with steeper increases in states that already had higher proportions of religiously unaffiliated people, suggesting regional cultural momentum in secularization. (Visual: U.S. map with state-level “nones” data.)
- 2019–2020: In the UK’s Avon Longitudinal Study, larger proportions of young adults (born 1991–1992) identified as “nones,” agnostic, or atheist, with about 3% consistently reporting “other” beliefs, reflecting a trend toward personalized, non-institutional spirituality. (Visual: Cohort belief distribution chart.)
- 2020: During the COVID-19 pandemic, global Google searches for “prayer” surged by 10% above baseline, with increases across all continents, income levels, and religions except Buddhism, indicating a crisis-driven return to private religiosity even as physical gatherings declined. (Visual: Global “prayer search” heatmap over time.)
- 2020: A U.S. study found that self-reported decreases in religiosity (importance, prayer, attendance, community connection) during the pandemic were associated with lower overall flourishing, suggesting a complex relationship between crisis, faith, and well-being. (Visual: Scatter plot of religiosity change vs. well-being scores.)
- 2021: Research on American religious life found that while most sexual minorities are among the least religious, Black sexual minority women with college degrees meditate more frequently than any other group considered, highlighting intersectional patterns in religious practice. (Visual: Intersectional identity matrix with meditation frequency.)
- 2022: In Germany, Muslim youth (58%) were far more likely to maintain high religiosity into early adulthood compared to immigrant-origin Christians (32% medium, 68% low) and non-immigrant Christians (74% low), challenging the assumption that religious decline is universal among youth in Western societies. (Visual: Religious trajectory by group, line chart.)
Sources
- https://journals.kmanpub.com/index.php/jayps/article/view/3658
- https://rsisinternational.org/journals/ijriss/articles/the-impact-of-traditional-madrasah-and-mbhte-elementary-education-on-the-sama-dilaut-in-simunul-tawi-tawi/
- https://qtanalytics.in/journals/index.php/IJERR/article/view/5244
- https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1111/1468-4446.12205
- https://www.taylorfrancis.com/books/9781351257756
- http://www.ubplj.org/index.php/dlj/article/view/1766
- https://www.semanticscholar.org/paper/41f8c585dc33516589fd86e320302d05885536c2
- https://www.semanticscholar.org/paper/df2918f83345d42acbdb1de8fcc49159276aa14d
- https://utppublishing.com/doi/10.3138/tjt.23.2.109
- https://www.semanticscholar.org/paper/22236ae8c264566db8b63e5e47cd1f983387b317